Mauritius vs. Seychelles: Which Island Is The Perfect Match for You?
“To escape and sit quietly on the beach—that’s my idea of paradise”
Longing for a piece of paradise to escape to for your next vacation? Maybe you're dreaming of getting away from work, staring out the window as it rains, and imagining yourself sipping a cocktail with an umbrella in hand while lounging on white sand beaches. Or perhaps you’re searching for the perfect honeymoon destination after the whirlwind of wedding planning. Either way, if you’ve been searching for stunning beaches and crystal-clear waters, you’ve probably come across two islands in the Indian Ocean: Mauritius and Seychelles. These destinations are popular for a reason – both offer breathtaking landscapes and unforgettable experiences. But which one to choose?
Mauritius is known for its vibrant culture and adventurous hikes, while Seychelles promises secluded beaches and luxury resorts perfect for a peaceful escape. And just to add a bit more to the mix, there’s a third contender: the Maldives. If you're wondering how it stacks up against the other two, you can read all about Maldives vs Seychelles here. But for now, let’s walk you through all that makes Mauritius and Seychelles so special, the differences between the two islands, and my personal recommendations. This way, you’ll have all the information you need to make the perfect choice for your next paradise getaway.
Let’s dive in!
How to travel to and around Mauritius vs. Seychelles
If you’re looking for a relaxing vacation, the last thing you want after a long flight is to spend hours traveling to your destination. Luckily, both Mauritius and Seychelles have the majority of their hotels located on the main island. Since neither island is particularly huge, you won’t have to worry about long transfers. Most accomodations are just a short car ride away from the airport, and whether you choose to have a driver from the hotel pick you up or decide to rent a car and explore on your own, getting to your destination is quick and easy.
Mauritius
Getting around Mauritius is a breeze, with most resorts just a short drive from the airport – typically around 45 minutes to an hour, depending on where you're staying. The island is small enough that you can easily explore it at your own pace. If you're looking to get out and see more, renting a car is a great option. The roads are well-maintained and not particularly challenging, though it’s important to remember that you’ll be driving on the left side of the road. Don’t worry, though – the roads in most areas aren’t narrow or steep, and traffic is usually manageable. Parking is also quite easy to find, so you won’t have trouble navigating the island.
Alternatively, many hotels and resorts offer private tours, which can be a great way to explore without the hassle. These tours typically focus on one part of the island – the north or the south. The north tour includes visits to the capital city, Grand Baie, and the beautiful botanical gardens. The south tour covers the tea factory, La Vallée Des Couleurs Nature Park, and ancient temples. Whether you decide to rent a car or opt for a guided tour, you’ll have no shortage of ways to explore the island.
Seychelles
Getting around Seychelles is a bit different from Mauritius. While most resorts are located just a short drive from the airport – typically around 20 to 45 minutes – the roads can be more challenging. The island’s steep, narrow roads wind up and down with sharp turns, which can make navigating tricky, especially when driving on the left side of the road (something I personally find a bit challenging!). Because of this, I chose to explore with a driver/guide, which was a great option. If you’re planning to get out and explore on your own, though, renting a car is still an option. Unlike Mauritius, where you might spread your adventures over several days, you can hit most of Seychelles' highlights in just one day, from the botanical gardens and the main city to scenic viewpoints.
How to pick a hotel/resort in the Maldives vs Seychelles
When choosing a hotel in Mauritius or Seychelles, location is key. Both islands offer a range of accommodations, from beachfront resorts to more secluded retreats, so it really depends on what kind of experience you’re after. If you’re seeking privacy and seclusion, you can opt for a resort that offers more remote, natural surroundings. Both destinations have plenty of options but keep in mind what kind of activities you want to do, how accessible you want your resort to be, and whether you prefer a more tranquil or lively atmosphere.
Mauritius
Mauritius offers a variety of hotel options, all located on the main island. For those seeking luxury, the most upscale resorts are generally found on the east side of the island, where the beaches are softer and more pristine. The west side, while beautiful, tends to have more rocks along the coast, which makes it less ideal for lounging by the sea. Many of the luxury resorts on the east side are set in more secluded areas, making them perfect for those looking for serenity and privacy. On the other hand, if you're looking for a more lively atmosphere, Grand Baie on the north coast is the place to be, offering a vibrant scene with shops, restaurants, and nightlife.
During my stay in Mauritius, I had the opportunity to experience four different hotels: One&Only Le Saint Géran, Four Seasons Resort Mauritius at Anahita, Anantara Iko Mauritius Resort & Villas, and Shangri-La’s Le Touessrok Resort & Spa. Each offered a unique take on the island's charm and luxury. You can read more about the best (and not-so-best) hotels in my guide to Mauritius hotels here.
Seychelles
When it comes to choosing a hotel in Seychelles, some are located on the main island of Mahé, like the popular Savoy Resort & Spa and Four Seasons Resort Seychelles, which offer easy access to local attractions and the island's stunning beaches. However, there are also more exclusive options located on smaller islands. For example, North Island, which is known for its privacy and luxury, is where Prince William and Kate Middleton spent their honeymoon. These remote islands provide an unparalleled level of seclusion, perfect for those looking to escape the crowds and indulge in a truly private experience.
As I’ve stayed at many Anantara properties before, I decided to stay at Anantara Maia Seychelles Villas for a unique experience. We stayed in the Ocean View Pool Villa, perched on a cliff with a magnificent view of the island and the ocean. The resort operates with a Beyond All-Inclusive concept, meaning you can order anything, anytime—including cocktails and wines. Since the accommodation is located on a cliff, you’ll need to walk uphill from the beach or restaurant to get there. But don't worry, you won’t need to leave your villa much, though the resort provides buggies that you can call to take you up and down the hill with ease. If you’re looking for complete serenity and luxury, this place truly delivers.
Want to know more about Anantara Maia Seychelles? You got it!
What to do on Mauritius vs. Seychelles
When it comes to things to do in Mauritius and Seychelles, both destinations offer a wealth of experiences. Mauritius is known for its blend of beautiful beaches and cultural attractions, offering everything from vibrant markets and historical sites to water sports and nature reserves. On the other hand, Seychelles takes a more laid-back approach, with its pristine beaches and crystal-clear waters. Whether you're into relaxing on the beach, exploring marine life, or trekking through nature reserves, both islands promise unforgettable memories. While both offer relaxation and adventure, the atmosphere and experiences on each island are distinctly different. Choosing between the two ultimately depends on what you're expecting from your vacation.
Mauritius
In Mauritius, there's no shortage of exciting things to do, whether you're looking for adventure or relaxation. Explore the island's stunning beaches, go snorkeling or diving in crystal-clear waters, or take part in thrilling water sports like kite surfing. For nature lovers, Mauritius offers lush hiking trails, especially in places like Black River Gorges National Park, where you can enjoy breathtaking views and discover local wildlife. Be sure to visit the famous Chamarel Colored Earths, where you can witness the striking seven-colored sands, and don't miss the stunning Underwater Waterfall, a breathtaking natural phenomenon visible from a helicopter ride.
If you're after a dose of culture, head to the capital city of Port Louis, where you can visit markets, museums, and the famous Pamplemousses Botanical Garden. And if you're looking to experience some nightlife, Grand Baie is the place to be, with its vibrant bars and lively atmosphere. Whether you're diving into the rich history, soaking up the sun on pristine beaches, or exploring the island’s natural wonders, there's something for everyone. To help plan your perfect trip, check out my comprehensive Mauritius Travel Guide for all the tips and must-see spots.
Seychelles
Seychelles offers a wealth of experiences that blend natural beauty and adventure. The islands are famous for their pristine beaches, where you can relax, snorkel, or dive in some of the clearest waters you'll ever find. For a more active day, explore the unique granite formations on La Digue Island or hike through lush nature reserves like the Vallée de Mai, a UNESCO World Heritage site. Don’t miss the chance to visit the famous Anse Source d'Argent, one of the most photographed beaches in the world.
For those looking for something truly spectacular, a boat tour around the islands offers incredible views of the crystal-clear waters and the chance to spot rare wildlife, including giant tortoises. You can also take a helicopter ride to see the breathtaking scenery from above, giving you a unique perspective of the islands. If you're after a more lively atmosphere, Victoria, the capital, offers local markets and cultural experiences, while the island of Mahé provides quiet relaxation.
So where should I go next? The Verdict.
Overall, both Mauritius and Seychelles are incredible destinations, each offering its own unique charm, but the choice ultimately depends on the kind of experience you're after. If you’re someone who enjoys venturing out and exploring—whether that’s hiking, visiting temples, or soaking up the culture—Mauritius is the place for you. With its variety of landscapes, lively towns, and cultural offerings, it’s ideal for those who want a bit more to do beyond the beaches. Seychelles, on the other hand, is smaller and offers more of a secluded, tranquil vibe. If you're looking for 75% relaxation but 25% activities, then Seychelles is the place for you. With its pristine beaches and laid-back atmosphere, it’s the perfect destination for those seeking peace and serenity with a few activities to enjoy on the side. In terms of accommodations, Seychelles tends to offer more secluded options, many with private pools and villas, giving you that exclusive feel. While Mauritius is no less luxurious, its hotels tend to feel a little more clustered together, especially in the busier areas. When it comes to price, Mauritius, being a larger island, offers a wider range of options, including more budget-friendly choices, which makes it a better destination if you’re traveling on a tighter budget.
In summary, from my experience, it comes down to this: if you want a larger, more varied island experience, Mauritius has it all—but if you’re after the true "secluded paradise island" vibe, Seychelles wins. Personally, I preferred Seychelles for its intimate and peaceful atmosphere.
One important side note I think is worth mentioning is that Mauritius does have a noticeable issue with stray dogs and cats, and I hadn’t experienced this to this extent in other destinations. This seems to be a bigger problem than I realized, and it’s definitely something to keep in mind because wherever you go/stay, you will see it.
I hope this was helpful. If you have any more questions, you can always reach out here or on Instagram, I’m more than happy to answer any of your questions.
